Mean squared error of ridge estimators in logistic regression

Blagus, R.; Goeman, J.J.

doi:doi:10.1111/stan.12201

It is well known that the maximum likelihood estimator (MLE) is inadmissible when estimating the multidimensional Gaussian location parameter. We show that the verdict is much more subtle for the binary location parameter. We consider this problem in a regression framework by considering a ridge logistic regression (RR) with three alternative ways of shrinking the estimates of the event probabilities. While it is shown that all three variants reduce the mean squared error (MSE) of the MLE, there is at the same time, for every amount of shrinkage, a true value of the location parameter for which we are overshrinking, thus implying the minimaxity of the MLE in this family of estimators. Little shrinkage also always reduces the MSE of individual predictions for all three RR estimators; however, only the naive estimator that shrinks toward 1/2 retains this property for any generalized MSE (GMSE). In contrast, for the two RR estimators that shrink toward the common mean probability,...Show more It is well known that the maximum likelihood estimator (MLE) is inadmissible when estimating the multidimensional Gaussian location parameter. We show that the verdict is much more subtle for the binary location parameter. We consider this problem in a regression framework by considering a ridge logistic regression (RR) with three alternative ways of shrinking the estimates of the event probabilities. While it is shown that all three variants reduce the mean squared error (MSE) of the MLE, there is at the same time, for every amount of shrinkage, a true value of the location parameter for which we are overshrinking, thus implying the minimaxity of the MLE in this family of estimators. Little shrinkage also always reduces the MSE of individual predictions for all three RR estimators; however, only the naive estimator that shrinks toward 1/2 retains this property for any generalized MSE (GMSE). In contrast, for the two RR estimators that shrink toward the common mean probability, there is always a GMSE for which even a minute amount of shrinkage increases the error. These theoretical results are illustrated on a numerical example. The estimators are also applied to a real data set, and practical implications of our results are discussed.
Show less

Leiden University Scholarly Publications

View statistics

Documents

In Collections

Mean squared error of ridge estimators in logistic regression