Patients with chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD) may benefit from palliative care including advance care planning, because of their severe symptom burden and high mortality rates. However... Show morePatients with chronic obstructive pulmonary disease (COPD) may benefit from palliative care including advance care planning, because of their severe symptom burden and high mortality rates. However, this care is poorly implemented due to various reasons. Therefore, this thesis aimed to study the effectiveness of palliative care for patients with COPD and how a palliative care approach can be successfully integrated into regular COPD care.A national survey among pulmonologists and general practitioners was conducted to identify the current content and organization of palliative care in COPD in the Netherlands (Chapter 2). A systematic review revealed that very little was known about the effectiveness of palliative care interventions in COPD and how best to implement it in practice (Chapter 3). To close this knowledge gap, the COMPASSION study was designed (Chapter 4). In a cluster randomized controlled trial in eight hospital regions, health care providers of intervention regions were trained to identify palliative patients with COPD using the ProPal-COPD tool, do advance care planning conversations, and manage dyspnea. The effectiveness on patient outcomes was studied (Chapter 5) and factors for successful implementation identified (Chapter 6). Finally, the ProPal-COPD tool was externally validated and user experiences examined (Chapter 7). Show less
Steen, J.T. van der; Engels, Y.; Touwen, D.P.; Kars, M.C.; Reyners, A.K.L.; Linden, Y.M. van der; Korfage, I.J. 2023
The Dutch health care system fosters a strong public health sector offering accessible generalist care including generalist palliative care. General practitioners are well positioned to conduct... Show moreThe Dutch health care system fosters a strong public health sector offering accessible generalist care including generalist palliative care. General practitioners are well positioned to conduct ACP, for example, to continue or initiate conversations after hospitalization. However, research shows that ACP conversations are often ad hoc and in frail patients, ACP is often only initiated when admitted to a nursing home by elderly care physicians who are on the staff. Tools that raise awareness of triggers to initiate ACP, screening tools, information brochures, checklists and training have been developed and implemented with funding by national programs which currently focus on implementation projects rather than or in addition to, research. The programs commonly require educational deliverables, patient and public involvement and addressing diversity in patient groups. A major challenge is how to implement ACP systematically and continuously across sectors and disciplines in a way that supports a proactive yet person-centered approach rather than an approach with an exclusive focus on medical procedures. Digital solutions can support continuity of care and communication about care plans. Solutions should fit a culture that prefers trust-based, informal deliberative approaches. This may be supported by involving disciplines other than medicine, such as nursing and spiritual caregiving, and public health approaches. Show less
Abate, Y.; Solomon, K.; Azmera, Y.M.; Fouw, M. de; Kaba, M. 2023
Background Annually 57 million people across the globe require palliative care, 76% are from low- and-middle income countries. Continuity of palliative care contributes to a decline in emergency... Show moreBackground Annually 57 million people across the globe require palliative care, 76% are from low- and-middle income countries. Continuity of palliative care contributes to a decline in emergency room visits., decreased hospital deaths, improved patient satisfaction, better utilization of services, and cost savings. Despite efforts made to develop the palliative care guideline in Ethiopia, the service is not yet organized and linked to primary health care. This study aimed to explore barriers to the continuum of palliative care from facility to household for cancer patients in Addis Ababa. Methods Qualitative exploratory study was conducted with face-to-face interviews with a total of 25 participants. The study population was adult cancer patients, primary caregivers, healthcare providers, volunteers, and nationwide advocates. Data were audio recorded, transcribed verbatim and finally imported to Open code version 4.02 software for coding and analysis. Thematic analysis was guided by Tanahashi’s framework. Results The key barriers to continuity of palliative care included opioid scarcity and turnover and shortage of healthcare workers. A shortfall of diagnostic materials, cost of medications, lack of government backing, and homebased center’s enrollment capacity hampered accessibility. Care providers were instruments of cultural barriers in delivering appropriate end-of-life care, on the other hand, patients’ preference for conventional medicine hindered acceptability. Lack of community volunteers, failure of health extension workers to link patients, and spatial limits fraught utilization. The lack of defined roles and services at several levels and the workload on healthcare professionals affected the effectiveness of the nexus. Conclusion The continuum of palliative care service from health facility to household in Ethiopia is yet in its infancy compromised by factors related to availability, accessibility, acceptability, utilization, and effectiveness. Further research is required to delineate the roles of various actors; th Show less
BackgroundNon-communicable diseases are currently the leading cause of death in the Netherlands. Meeting the increasingly complex care needs of patients with these diseases is demanding for society... Show moreBackgroundNon-communicable diseases are currently the leading cause of death in the Netherlands. Meeting the increasingly complex care needs of patients with these diseases is demanding for society and our healthcare services.Specialist palliative care diminishes inappropriate end-of-life care and improves quality of life for patients with advanced cancer and other life-limiting diseases.Aims & MethodsUsing 2 national cross-sectional surveys and 2 population-based observational studies, we assessed the value, availability and accessibility of palliative care in the Dutch healthcare system. Using a modified Delphi technique, we developed a national quality framework for palliative care with key elements for integration with regular care.ResultsTimely provision of generalist and specialist palliative care is associated with significantly less potentially inappropriate end-of-life care for patients with advanced cancer.The majority of patients with cancer received no palliative care or only in their last weeks or days of life. Specialist palliative care teams were found to be available in almost all hospitals, but referrals to these teams were consistently low. Our findings implicate a limited availability and accessibility of palliative care.Eight key elements of the Netherlands Quality Framework for Palliative Care were prioritised to improve availability and accessibility to quality palliative care. Show less
Dementia is a progressive, life-limiting disease. A palliative approach to care, that focuses on the quality of life of people with dementia and their relatives, is therefore indicated. Advance... Show moreDementia is a progressive, life-limiting disease. A palliative approach to care, that focuses on the quality of life of people with dementia and their relatives, is therefore indicated. Advance care planning is core to palliative care. Relatives play a major role in this, because people with dementia often become unable to indicate their preferences for future care. Palliative dementia care is still sub optimally implemented, however. Nursing home staff and relatives of people with dementia need information about dementia and palliative care to ensure it is optimally implemented. Also, ongoing communication between everyone involved in the care of a person with dementia is required, including discussions about future care needs. This facilitates a palliative care approach in dementia. These conclusions result from a survey among elderly care physicians, a systematic review, care plan data in nursing homes and an intervention study in two nursing homes: the mySupport study. It appears that relatives want timely information about the end of life with dementia. That way they can prepare. Although physicians are usually the ones who educate relatives, nursing staff often have a stronger relationship with relatives. After training, they can play an important role in providing information. Show less
Objectives: Little direction exists on how to effectively implement palliative care for patients with COPD. In the COMPASSION study, we developed, executed, and evaluated a multifaceted... Show moreObjectives: Little direction exists on how to effectively implement palliative care for patients with COPD. In the COMPASSION study, we developed, executed, and evaluated a multifaceted implementation strategy to improve the uptake of region-tailored palliative care intervention components into routine COPD care. We evaluated the implementation strategy and assessed the implementation process, barriers, and facilitators. Methods: A mixed methods process evaluation was performed. Primary and secondary healthcare providers in four hospital regions in the Netherlands were trained. Patients identified during hospitalisation for an acute exacerbation received palliative care and were followed for a year. Various sources were used: process data, questionnaires including the End-of-life Professional Caregiver Survey (EPCS), medical records, monitoring meetings, and interviews. The Consolidated Framework of Implementation Research (CFIR) was used to categorize implementation determinants. Results: The training sessions with roleplay were positively evaluated and increased professionals' self-efficacy in providing palliative care statistically significantly. Of 98 patients identified, 44 (44.9%) received one or more palliative care conversations at the outpatient clinic. Having those conversations was highly valued by healthcare providers because it led to clarity and peace of mind for the patient and higher job satisfaction. Coordination and continuity remained suboptimal. Most important barriers to implementation were time constraints, the COVID-19 pandemic, and barriers related to transmural and interdisciplinary collaboration. Facilitators were the systematic screening of patients for palliative care needs, adapting to the patient's readiness, conducting palliative care conversations with a pulmonologist and a COPD nurse together, and meeting regularly with a small team led by a dedicated implementation leader. Conclusions: Providing integrated palliative care for patients with COPD is highly valued by healthcare providers but remains challenging. Our findings will guide future implementation efforts. Future research should focus on how to optimize transmural and interdisciplinary collaboration. Show less
This thesis aimed to find opportunities to improve proactivity and patient-centredness in palliative care, focussing on education and care outcomes. The 2009 national blueprint on medical education... Show moreThis thesis aimed to find opportunities to improve proactivity and patient-centredness in palliative care, focussing on education and care outcomes. The 2009 national blueprint on medical education and the Dutch medical curricula did not comprise all essential elements about end-of-life care. Factors associated with approaching death in patients with advanced cancer visiting the LUMC’s Emergency Department (ED) in the last three months of life were lung cancer, neurologic deterioration, dyspnoea, hypercalcemia and jaundice. Patients with haematological malignancies received more potentially inappropriate care than advanced cancer patients. They rarely had limitations on life-sustaining treatments, although they often died of disease progression or treatment toxicity. The surprise question (SQ) is a simple tool to identify patients with palliative care needs . Adding poor performance status to the SQ improved the predictive value for one-year mortality in advanced cancer patients visiting the LUMC’s ED. The Leiden Guide on Palliative Care (LGP) was developed by the Centre of Expertise in Palliative Care to assess symptom burden and information needs. Patients and family wanted information about current problems and about their worries. Patients, family and clinicians found the LGP helpful. Using their input, the LGP was improved for use by generalist palliative care clinicians. Show less
Harding, A.J.E.; Doherty, J.; Bavelaar, L.; Walshe, C.; Preston, N.; Kaasalainen, S.; ... ; MySupport Study Group 2022
Background: Where it has been determined that a resident in a nursing home living with dementia loses decisional capacity, nursing home staff must deliver care that is in the person's best... Show moreBackground: Where it has been determined that a resident in a nursing home living with dementia loses decisional capacity, nursing home staff must deliver care that is in the person's best interests. Ideally, decisions should be made involving those close to the person, typically a family carer and health and social care providers. The aim of the Family Carer Decisional Support intervention is to inform family carers on end-of-life care options for a person living with advanced dementia and enable them to contribute to advance care planning. This implementation study proposes to; 1) adopt and apply the intervention internationally; and, 2) train nursing home staff to deliver the family carer decision support intervention. Methods: This study will employ a multiple case study design to allow an understanding of the implementation process and to identify the factors which determine how well the intervention will work as intended. We will enrol nursing homes from each country (Canada n = 2 Republic of Ireland = 2, three regions in the UK n = 2 each, The Netherlands n = 2, Italy n = 2 and the Czech Republic n = 2) to reflect the range of characteristics in each national and local context. The RE-AIM (reach, effectiveness, adoption, implementation, maintenance) framework will guide the evaluation of implementation of the training and information resources. Our mixed methods study design has three phases to (1) establish knowledge about the context of implementation, (2) participant baseline information and measures and (3) follow up evaluation. Discussion: The use of a multiple case study design will enable evaluation of the intervention in different national, regional, cultural, clinical, social and organisational contexts, and we anticipate collecting rich and in-depth data. While it is hoped that the intervention resources will impact on policy and practice in the nursing homes that are recruited to the study, the development of implementation guidelines will ensure impact on wider national policy and practice. It is our aim that the resources will be sustainable beyond the duration of the study and this will enable the resources to have a longstanding relevance for future advance care planning practice for staff, family carers and residents with advanced dementia. Show less
Dijxhoorn, A.F.; Raijmakers, N.; Linden, Y. van der; Leget, C.; Brom, L. 2022
Objectives. Many aspects of palliative care, such as managing (complicated) symptoms, conductinggoals-of-care conversations, and repeated exposure to loss, can be stressful to clinicians.Previous... Show moreObjectives. Many aspects of palliative care, such as managing (complicated) symptoms, conductinggoals-of-care conversations, and repeated exposure to loss, can be stressful to clinicians.Previous research on the emotional impact of providing palliative care was mainlydone in specialist settings. However, the majority of palliative care is provided by clinicianswho are not specialized in palliative care, and can be supported by palliative care specialistsonly when needed. Therefore, this study aimed to gain insight into the emotional impactof providing palliative care on clinicians, both palliative care generalists and specialists.Methods. A qualitative interview study among 21 clinicians (11 doctors and 10 nurses) workingin hospitals, home care, or nursing homes in the Netherlands was conducted. BetweenFebruary and June 2019, 13 palliative care generalists and 8 specialists were interviewed.Interviews were thematically analyzed by two researchers.Results. All clinicians considered the emotional impact of providing palliative care to be substantialand experienced both positive and negative aspects of providing palliative care. Severalaspects of providing palliative care can support or undermine emotional stability. These socalledfacilitators and barriers, such as practicing self-care and complexity of palliative care,were found at three different levels: individual, team, and organization.Significance of results. Although clinicians experience providing palliative care as meaningfuland valuable, the emotional impact is considerable. Negative and positive aspects often coexist.Further insight into the dynamics and magnitude of the emotional impact of providingpalliative care is needed in order to create a healthy working environment and develop adequateinterventions. Show less
BackgroundTo support family caregivers of people with dementia in end-of-life decision making, a family booklet on comfort care has been adapted and adopted by several European jurisdictions since... Show moreBackgroundTo support family caregivers of people with dementia in end-of-life decision making, a family booklet on comfort care has been adapted and adopted by several European jurisdictions since the original publication in Canada in 2005.MethodsWe analyzed and compared the adaptations to the family booklets used in Canada, the Czech Republic, Italy, the Netherlands, the UK and Ireland that were made up to 2021. Qualitative content analysis was used to create a typology of changes to the original booklet. Interviews with the teams that adapted the booklets contributed to methodological triangulation. Further, using an established framework, we assessed whether the contents of the booklets addressed all domains relevant to optimal palliative dementia care.ResultsThe booklets differed in the types of treatment addressed, in particular tube feeding, euthanasia, and spiritual care. There was also variability in the extent to which medical details were provided, an emphasis on previously expressed wishes in medical decision making, addressing of treatment dilemmas at the end of life, the tone of the messages (indirect or explicit) and the discussion of prognosis (as more or less positive), and the involvement of various healthcare professionals and family caregivers in care. All booklets addressed all domains of palliative dementia care.ConclusionsWe identified core elements in providing information on end-of-life care to family caregivers of people with dementia as related to optimal palliative care in dementia. Additionally, local adaptations and updates are required to account for socio-cultural, clinical, and legal differences which may also change over time. These results may inform development of educational and advance care planning materials for different contexts. Show less
Background Specialist palliative care teams (SPCTs) in hospitals improve quality of life and satisfaction with care for patients with advanced disease. However, referrals to SPCTs are often limited... Show moreBackground Specialist palliative care teams (SPCTs) in hospitals improve quality of life and satisfaction with care for patients with advanced disease. However, referrals to SPCTs are often limited. To identify areas for improvement of SPCTs' service penetration, we explored the characteristics and level of integration of palliative care programmes and SPCTs in Dutch hospitals and we assessed the relation between these characteristics and specialist palliative care referral rates. Methods We performed a secondary analysis of a national cross-sectional survey conducted among hospitals in the Netherlands from March through May 2018. For this survey, a previously developed online questionnaire, containing 6 consensus-based integration indicators, was sent to palliative care programme leaders in all 78 hospitals. For referral rate we calculated the number of annual inpatient referrals to the SPCT as a percentage of the number of total annual hospital admissions. Referral rate was dichotomized into high (>= third quartile) and low (< third quartile). Characteristics of SPCTs with high and low referral rate were compared using univariate analyses. P-values < 0.05 were considered significant. Results In total, 63 hospitals (81%) participated in the survey, of which 62 had an operational SPCT. The palliative care programmes of these hospitals consisted of inpatient consultation services (94%), interdisciplinary staffing (61%), outpatient clinics (45%), dedicated acute care beds (21%) and community-based palliative care (27%). The median referral rate was 0.56% (IQR 0.23-1.0%), ranging from 0 to 3.7%. Comparing SPCTs with high referral rate (>= 1%, n = 17) and low referral rate (< 1%, n = 45) showed significant differences for SPCTs' years of existence, staffing, their level of education, participation in other departments' team meetings, provision of education and conducting research. With regard to integration, significant differences were found for the presence of outpatient clinics and timing of referrals. Conclusion In the Netherlands, palliative care programmes and specialist palliative care teams in hospitals vary in their level of integration and development, with more mature teams showing higher referral rates. Appropriate staffing, dedicated outpatient clinics, education and research appear means to improve service penetration and timing of referral for patients with advanced diseases. Show less
Engel, M.; Stoppelenburg, A.; Ark, A. van der; Bols, F.M.; Bruggeman, J.; Janssens-van Vliet, E.C.J.; ... ; Heide, A. van der 2021
BackgroundIn the Netherlands, healthcare professionals attending patients in the last phase of life, can consult an expert palliative care team (PCT) in case of complex problems. There are two... Show moreBackgroundIn the Netherlands, healthcare professionals attending patients in the last phase of life, can consult an expert palliative care team (PCT) in case of complex problems. There are two types of PCTs: regional PCTs, which are mainly consulted by general practitioners, and hospital PCTs, which are mainly consulted by healthcare professionals in the hospital. Integration of these PCTs is expected to facilitate continuity of care for patients receiving care in different settings. We studied facilitators and barriers in the process of developing and implementing an integrated transmural palliative care consultation service.MethodsA multiple case study was performed in four palliative care networks in the southwest Netherlands. We aimed to develop an integrated transmural palliative care consultation service. Researchers were closely observing the process and participated in project team meetings. A within-case analysis was conducted for each network, using the Consolidated Framework for Implementation Research (CFIR). Subsequently, all findings were pooled.ResultsIn each network, project team members thought that the core goal of a transmural consultation service is improvement of continuity of palliative care for patients throughout their illness trajectory. It was nevertheless a challenge for hospital and non-hospital healthcare professionals to arrive at a shared view on goals, activities and working procedures of the transmural consultation service. All project teams experienced the lack of evidence-based guidance on how to organise the service as a barrier. The role of the management of the involved care organisations was sometimes perceived as unsupportive, and different financial reimbursement systems for hospital and out-of-hospital care made implementation of a transmural consultation service complex. Three networks managed to develop and implement a transmural service at some level, one network did not manage to do so.ConclusionsHealthcare professionals are motivated to collaborate in a transmural palliative care consultation service, because they believe it can contribute to high-quality palliative care. However, they need more shared views on goals and activities of a transmural consultation service, more guidance on organisational issues and appropriate financing. Further research is needed to provide evidence on benefits and costs of different models of integrated transmural palliative care consultation services. Show less
Klapwijk, M.S.; Dekker, N.L.; Caljouw, M.A.A.; Achterberg, W.P.; Steen, J.T. van der 2020
BackgroundThe Liverpool care pathway for the dying patient (LCP) is a multidisciplinary tool developed for the dying phase for use in palliative care settings. The literature reports divergent... Show moreBackgroundThe Liverpool care pathway for the dying patient (LCP) is a multidisciplinary tool developed for the dying phase for use in palliative care settings. The literature reports divergent experiences with its application in a nursing home setting related to its implementation and staff competencies. The aim of this study is to understand how the LCP is being used in the context of the nursing home, including for residents with dementia, and experienced from the perspectives of those responsible for medical treatment in nursing homes.MethodsA mixed-methods approach was used, consisting of a survey followed by interviews. A link to a 9-item online survey with closed and open-ended questions was emailed to all physicians and nurse practitioners of 33 care organisations with nursing homes in three regions of the Netherlands (North, West and South). In addition, 10 respondents with particularly positive or negative experiences were selected for semi-structured interviews.ResultsThe survey was completed by 159 physicians and nurse practitioners. The respondents were very positive on the content and less positive on the use of the LCP, although they reported difficulties identifying the right time to start the LCP, especially in case of dementia. Also using the LCP was more complicated after the implementation of the electronic health record. The LCP was judged to be a marker of quality for the assessment of symptoms in the dying phase and communication with relatives.ConclusionAn instrument that prompts regular assessment of a dying person was perceived by those responsible for (medical) care to contribute to good care. As such, the LCP was valued, but there was a clear need to start it earlier than in the last days or hours of life, a need for a shorter version, and for integration of the LCP in the electronic health record. Regular assessments with an instrument that focusses on quality of care and good symptom control can improve palliative care for nursing home residents with and without dementia. Show less
Alili, M. el; Smaling, H.J.A.; Joling, K.J.; Achterberg, W.P.; Francke, A.L.; Bosmans, J.E.; Steen, J.T. van der 2020
Background: Dementia is a progressive disease that decreases quality of life of persons with dementia and is associated with high societal costs. The burden of caring for persons with dementia also... Show moreBackground: Dementia is a progressive disease that decreases quality of life of persons with dementia and is associated with high societal costs. The burden of caring for persons with dementia also decreases the quality of life of family caregivers. The objective of this study was to assess the societal cost-effectiveness of Namaste Care Family program in comparison with usual care in nursing home residents with advanced dementia.Methods: Nursing homes were randomized to either Namaste Care Family program or usual care. Outcome measures of the cluster-randomized trial in 231 residents included Quality of Life in Late-Stage Dementia (QUALID) and the Gain in Alzheimer Care Instrument (GAIN) for family caregivers over 12 months of follow-up. Health states were measured using the EQ-5D-3L questionnaire which were translated into utilities. QALYs were calculated by multiplying the amount of time a participant spent in a specific health state with the utility score associated with that health state. Healthcare utilization costs were estimated using standard unit costs, while intervention costs were estimated using a bottom-up approach. Missing cost and effect data were imputed using multiple imputation. Bootstrapped multilevel models were used after multiple imputation. Cost-effectiveness acceptability curves were estimated.Results: The Namaste Care Family program was more effective than usual care in terms of QUALID (- 0.062, 95%CI: - 0.40 to 0.28), QALY (0.0017, 95%CI: - 0.059 to 0.063) and GAIN (0.075, 95%CI: - 0.20 to 0.35). Total societal costs were lower for the Namaste Care Family program as compared to usual care (- 552 euro, 95%CI: - 2920 to 1903). However, these differences were not statistically significant. The probability of cost-effectiveness at a ceiling ratio of 0 euro/unit of effect extra was 0.70 for the QUALID, QALY and GAIN.Conclusions: The Namaste Care Family program is dominant over usual care and, thus, cost-effective, although statistical uncertainty was considerable. Show less
Verhoef, M.J.; Nijs, E. de; Horeweg, N.; Fogteloo, J.; Heringhaus, C.; Jochems, A.; ... ; Linden, Y. van der 2020
Purpose Patients with advanced cancer commonly visit the emergency department (ED) during the last 3 months of life. Identification of these patients and their palliative care needs help initiating... Show morePurpose Patients with advanced cancer commonly visit the emergency department (ED) during the last 3 months of life. Identification of these patients and their palliative care needs help initiating appropriate care according to patients' wishes. Our objective was to provide insight into ED visits of advanced cancer patients at the end of life. Methods Adult palliative patients with solid tumours who died < 3 months after their ED visit were included (2011-2014). Patients, ED visits, and follow-up were described. Factors associated with approaching death were assessed using Cox proportional hazards models. Results Four hundred twenty patients were included, 54.5% was male, median age 63 years. A total of 54.6% was on systemic anti-cancer treatments and 10.5% received home care >= 1 per day. ED visits were initiated by patients and family in 34.0% and 51.9% occurred during out-of-office hours. Dyspnoea (21.0%) or pain (18.6%) were most reported symptoms. Before the ED visit, limitations on life-sustaining treatments were discussed in 33.8%, during or after the ED visit in 70.7%. Median stay at the ED was 3:29 h (range 00:12-18:01 h), and 319 (76.0%) were hospitalized. Median survival was 18 days (IQ range 7-41). One hundred four (24.8%) died within 7 days after the ED visit, of which 71.2% in-hospital. Factors associated with approaching death were lung cancer, neurologic deterioration, dyspnoea, hypercalcemia, and jaundice. Conclusion ED visits of advanced cancer patients often lead to hospitalization and in-hospital deaths. Timely recognition of patients with limited life expectancies and urgent palliative care needs, and awareness among ED staff of the potential of ED-initiated palliative care may improve the end-of-life trajectory of these patients. Show less
Honinx, E.; Smets, T.; Piers, R.; Deliens, L.; Payne, S.; Kylanen, M.; ... ; European Forum Primary Care Age Pl 2019
