The results described in this thesis support the strong empirical evidence for the effectiveness of CBT-Ef for patients with an eating disorder and a BMI>17.5. When compared to TAU, we found... Show moreThe results described in this thesis support the strong empirical evidence for the effectiveness of CBT-Ef for patients with an eating disorder and a BMI>17.5. When compared to TAU, we found comparable effects on eating disorder psychopathology, however CBT-Ef is superior in enhancing self-esteem with significantly fewer sessions and within a shorter time. We found no support for the hypothesis that more severe self-esteem problems, higher levels of perfectionism, or more interpersonal problems would obstruct long-term improvement and would therefore need extra attention in an extended protocol. A broader use of CBT-Ef in clinical practice could result in more efficient and accessible treatment for patients with an eating disorder. In another study we found COMET to be effective in enhancing self-esteem in patients with an eating disorder. Since we did not find the predictive value of low self-esteem in CBT-E treatment outcome, we suggest to integrate COMET in an eating disorder treatment only when low self-esteem is pronounced and interferes with making progress. Show less
In this project we investigated the difference between efficacy (treatment outcome investigated in randomized clinical trials, RCTs) and effectiveness (treatment outcome when these treatments are... Show moreIn this project we investigated the difference between efficacy (treatment outcome investigated in randomized clinical trials, RCTs) and effectiveness (treatment outcome when these treatments are applied in daily psychiatric practice) for major depressive disorder. Treatment outcome and patient features in daily practice were assessed with routine outcome monitoring. We found that effectiveness is significantly lower than efficacy. In RCTs, a stringent patient selection is applied bij inclusion/exclusion criteria. We found that patients in daily practice do differ significantly from participants in RCTs with respect to baseline severity, comorbid disorders, suicidality and employment status. However, we found that these differences have very little influence on treatment outcome. In other words, if, hypothetically, only patients who are eligible for participation in RCTs for major depressive disorder would be tre ated, treatment success would not improve dramatically. Show less
Lem, R. van der; Wee, N.J.A. van der; Veen, T. van; Zitman, F.G. 2012