This dissertation covered several relevant cycles of placebo research with the main aim to optimize placebo effects in medical contexts. Firstly, a literature review described how the immune system... Show moreThis dissertation covered several relevant cycles of placebo research with the main aim to optimize placebo effects in medical contexts. Firstly, a literature review described how the immune system can be impacted by placebo effects and their underlying learning theories. In the following chapter, these learning theories were integrated to form an optimal research design by means of pharmacological conditioning to fit a specific patient group: children with juvenile idiopathic arthritis. Secondly, this dissertation focused on developing placebo information strategies to harness placebo beliefs and educate persons about the relevancy of placebo effects in practice. These insights are valuable because treatment expectations can have a positive or negative effect on treatment outcomes. Finally, insights from placebo learning theories and placebo information strategies were combined in an integrative experimental research design. This research design employed a more ethical form of placebo use because participants were made aware of placebos, called open-label placebos. In this last study we demonstrated that open-label placebo analgesia can be induced by combining learning theories and placebo information strategies. Altogether, this dissertation provided insights in learning mechanisms, communication strategies, and research paradigms that involve the optimization of placebo effects in medical context. Show less
Nocebo hyperalgesia is a clinically relevant phenomenon and may be formed as a result of associative learning, implemented by classical conditioning. This study explored for the first time distinct... Show moreNocebo hyperalgesia is a clinically relevant phenomenon and may be formed as a result of associative learning, implemented by classical conditioning. This study explored for the first time distinct nocebo conditioning methods and their consequences for nocebo attenuation methods. Healthy participants (N = 140) were recruited and randomized to the following nocebo hyperalgesia induction groups: conditioning with continuous reinforcement (CRF), conditioning with partial reinforcement (PRF), and a sham-conditioning control group. In the attenuation phase, counterconditioning was compared with extinction. During induction, participants experienced increased thermal pain in 100% of nocebo trials in the CRF groups, while in only 70% of nocebo trials in the PRF groups. During evocation, pain stimulation was equivalent across all trials. During attenuation, pain stimulation was decreased on nocebo trials relative to control trials for the counterconditioning groups, while pain remained equivalent across all trials for the extinction groups. Results showed that both PRF and CRF significantly induced nocebo hyperalgesia, but CRF was a more potent nocebo induction method, as compared to PRF. Counterconditioning was more effective than extinction in attenuating nocebo hyperalgesia. Neither CRF nor PRF resulted in resistance to extinction. However, compared with CRF, conditioning with PRF resulted in more resistance to counterconditioning. These findings demonstrate that the more ambiguous learning method of PRF can induce nocebo hyperalgesia and may potentially explain the treatment resistance and chronification seen in clinical practice. Further research is required to establish whether attenuation with counterconditioning is generalizable to clinical settings. Show less
This dissertation investigated placebo and nocebo effects in itch. Placebo and nocebo effects are positive and negative treatment outcomes respectively, that cannot be attributed to active... Show moreThis dissertation investigated placebo and nocebo effects in itch. Placebo and nocebo effects are positive and negative treatment outcomes respectively, that cannot be attributed to active treatment ingredients. Consistent with previous research, the dissertation shows that these effects play an important role in itch. The studies moreover illustrate that placebo effects can still occur when people are informed about them.The results described in this dissertation show that expectations about itch can be formed in various ways. People's expectations of treatment outcomes have been found underlie placebo and nocebo effects. For instance, the information that is given about how much itch an experimental test elicits (i.e., verbal suggestions) can influence expectations and lead to placebo or nocebo effects. The results also show that placebo effects can be automatically induced for itch by associative learning (through pharmacological conditioning). In addition, these effects may also occur when people know they are placebo effects. These results illustrate the importance of expectations and the psychosocial context in the treatment of somatic symptoms complaints such as itch. The results of this thesis may help improve existing treatments for itch. For example, medicine use can potentially be reduced by applying pharmacological conditioning, existing treatment can be improved by providing optimal treatment information, and the importance of expectations for treatment outcomes can be discussed with patients. Show less
In contrast to classical conditioning of physiological responses such as immune responses and drug effects, only a limited number of studies investigated classical conditioning of endocrine... Show moreIn contrast to classical conditioning of physiological responses such as immune responses and drug effects, only a limited number of studies investigated classical conditioning of endocrine responses. The present paper is the first systematic review that integrates evidence from animal and human trials regarding the possibility to condition the endocrine responses. Twenty-six animal and eight human studies were included in the review. We demonstrated that there is accumulating evidence that classical conditioning processes are able to influence specific endocrine responses, such as cortocosterone/cortisol and insulin, while more limited evidence exists for other hormones. Animal and human studies were generally consistent in their findings; however, the limited number of human studies makes it difficult to generalize and translate the results of animal research to humans. Next to methodological recommendations for future studies, we suggest several ways how classically conditioned endocrine responses can be used in clinical practice. Show less
