Why are both A-1${\mathbf{A}}<^>{-1}$ and (I-A)-1${(\mathbf{I}-\mathbf{A})}<^>{-1}$ used in life cycle assessment (LCA) matrix computations? This is a question that, in our experience... Show moreWhy are both A-1${\mathbf{A}}<^>{-1}$ and (I-A)-1${(\mathbf{I}-\mathbf{A})}<^>{-1}$ used in life cycle assessment (LCA) matrix computations? This is a question that, in our experience of teaching LCA, students often wonder about and struggle with. A brief survey of the literature suggests that the question can also confuse experienced LCA practitioners. Here, we seek to unify the computational structures of the two LCA approaches to achieve greater clarity and consistency, especially to make them easier to teach. We first show how small but crucial differences in the set-up of the two approaches lead to the use of A$\mathbf{A}$ versus I-A$\mathbf{I}-\mathbf{A}$. Then, we discuss the options to unify the presentations in a coherent way. We do not prescribe one way or the other. A larger point we hope to stress is the importance of unification, which may have both pedagogical and methodological benefits. Show less
Introduction Many methodological papers report a comparison of methods for LCA, for instance comparing different impact assessment systems, or developing streamlined methods. A popular way to do so... Show moreIntroduction Many methodological papers report a comparison of methods for LCA, for instance comparing different impact assessment systems, or developing streamlined methods. A popular way to do so is by studying the differences of results for a number of products. We refer to such studies as quasi-empirical meta-comparisons. Review of existing approaches A scan of the literature reveals that many different methods and indicators are employed: contribution analyses, Pearson correlations, Spearman correlations, regression, significance tests, neural networks, etc. Critical discussion We critically examine the current practice and conclude that some of the widely used methods are associated with important deficits. A new approach Inspired by the critical analysis, we develop a new approach for meta-comparative LCA, based on directional statistics. We apply it to several real-world test cases, and analyze its performance vis-a-vis traditional regression-based approaches. Conclusion The method on the basis of directional statistics withstands the tests of changing the scale and unit of the training data. As such, it holds a promise for improved method comparisons. Show less
Eco-efficiency is generally defined as the ratio of an economic and an environmental variable. This interpretation is also cited in connection to its most popular implementation, known as the "BASF... Show moreEco-efficiency is generally defined as the ratio of an economic and an environmental variable. This interpretation is also cited in connection to its most popular implementation, known as the "BASF eco-efficiency portfolio analysis". There is, however, something strange about this. A ratio is easily visualized as a slope, but BASF's method is working with a distance, which can be formulated as a weighted sum, not as a ratio. Upon closer analysis, it further shows that the two variables receive equal weight. These findings are contradicting the ISO 14045 standard and the perception in mainstream literature. We discuss the relevance of this shift of viewpoint. We also discuss some of the extensions, namely, the socio-efficiency analysis and the SEEbalance. We finally investigate the recent changes that were introduced in the eco-efficiency method, including an eco-efficiency index, and conclude that these changes have been reported in an incomplete way, or in documents that are difficult to trace. Effectively, this means that the most popular way to calculate and visualize eco-efficiency is unverifiable, impeding its status as a science-based method for sustainable industry support. We end by sketching the path forward. Show less
Limited and uneven distributed water resources have become one of the main obstacles to China's sustainable development, and the "virtual water hypothesis" (VWH) is expected to help mitigate water... Show moreLimited and uneven distributed water resources have become one of the main obstacles to China's sustainable development, and the "virtual water hypothesis" (VWH) is expected to help mitigate water stress. This study discusses the virtual water transfer pattern and water resources stress in China from the VWH perspective. Economic sectors in China are divided into land-dependent sectors and non-land-dependent sectors according to their dependence on specific local land types. Furthermore, the water resources withdrawal and utilization corresponding to these sectors are divided into land-dependent water resources (LDW) and non-land-dependent water resources (NLDW). Results show that the virtual LDW flows from economically poor to relatively developed regions, while the virtual NLDW flows in the opposite direction. LDW dominates Chinese water stress (78.2%) and virtual water flow (74.5%). Furthermore, the virtual water dominated by LDW ameliorates national water stress (the population under unsustainable water stress declined by 0.21 billion) but aggravates the imbalance of water resources between North and South. The transfer of virtual NLDW alleviates this imbalance slightly. Suitable land conditions play a decisive role in LDW withdrawal, which then cannot be replenished by virtual water. However, the withdrawal and transfer of NLDW are flexible, which should be a focus. The results point out that the possibility of water-rich regions as virtual water exporters is the key to alleviating the North-South water resource imbalance in China with VWH theory. Improvement of land productivity and water efficiency can be helpful to alleviate water stress. These findings may provide new insight into China's virtual water transfer pattern from the VWH perspective. Show less
The life cycle assessment (LCA) framework has established itself as the leading tool for the assessment of the environmental impact of products. Several works have established the need of... Show moreThe life cycle assessment (LCA) framework has established itself as the leading tool for the assessment of the environmental impact of products. Several works have established the need of integrating the LCA and risk analysis methodologies, due to the several common aspects. One of the ways to reach such integration is through guaranteeing that uncertainties in LCA modeling are carefully treated. It has been claimed that more attention should be paid to quantifying the uncertainties present in the various phases of LCA. Though the topic has been attracting increasing attention of practitioners and experts in LCA, there is still a lack of understanding and a limited use of the available statistical tools. In this work, we introduce a protocol to conduct global sensitivity analysis in LCA. The article focuses on the life cycle impact assessment (LCIA), and particularly on the relevance of global techniques for the development of trustable impact assessment models. We use a novel characterization model developed for the quantification of the impacts of noise on humans as a test case. We show that global SA is fundamental to guarantee that the modeler has a complete understanding of: (i) the structure of the model and (ii) the importance of uncertain model inputs and the interaction among them. Show less
One way to study complex systems is by methods from topological networktheory, that concentrate on the topological structure of the system interms of vertices (nodes) and edges that connect pairs... Show moreOne way to study complex systems is by methods from topological networktheory, that concentrate on the topological structure of the system interms of vertices (nodes) and edges that connect pairs of vertices. The lasttwo decades, topological network theory has seen a wide range of applications.In this paper, we explore its potential for two of the model systemsthat are central to industrial ecology (IE): life cycle assessment(LCA) and input-output analysis (IOA), with the aim of finding outwhether this theory offers insights that are useful to IE. We describe theprinciples of topological network theory, as well as the possible rules fortranslating LCA and IOA systems into a formal network. We apply thistheory to two cases, the ecoinvent LCA database, and the monetary IOtablefor the European Union in 2007. Our conclusions are mixed. It isnot entirely clear what the resulting network indicators imply for a specificLCA case or IOA case. Although the results obtained are perfectlyexplainable and thus do make sense, they appear to be very sensitive toarbitrary choices, such as the level of aggregation. Moreover, it appearsto be difficult to include the environmental aspect in the network analysis,so that we end up with analyzing an industrial network rather thanindustrial-ecological network Show less
Beames, A.; Broekx, S.; Heijungs, R.; Lookman, R.; Boonen, K.; Geert, Y. van; ... ; Seuntjes, P. 2015
The latest life-cycle assessment methods account for land use, due to the production, use and disposal of products and services, in terms of ecosystem damage. The process of brownfield remediation... Show moreThe latest life-cycle assessment methods account for land use, due to the production, use and disposal of products and services, in terms of ecosystem damage. The process of brownfield remediation converts otherwise idle urban space into productive space. The value to ecosystems in this context is of course limited since the brownfield site remains urban. When evaluating brownfield remediation technologies, the availability of space on-site is dependent on the duration of time required by the remediation technology to reach the remediation target. Remediation technology alternatives tend to vary largely in terms of duration. Comparative life-cycle assessments of remediation technologies, to date, present the large variations between alternatives in terms of remediation duration but do not translate this into an impact or parameter. The restored subsurface zone is often defined as a functional unit, when in fact the surface area is the resource restored by the remediation service. The economic benefits of making land resources available are particularly important considerations in the context of brownfield remediation. The research proposes an innovative impact assessment approach that allows land to be considered as a finite resource. The method is applied in a comparative life-cycle assessment of two potential remediation scenarios for an idle brownfield in the Brussels region of Belgium. The results show that there is a trade-off between greenhouse gas emissions and land availability and that both are largely dependent on the efficiency of the contaminant extraction mechanism. The results also raise the question as to whether the economic valuation of land, like precious metals and fossil fuels, provides an accurate reflection of the true value of the resource. Considering land as a resource at the midpoint level is also relevant in other urban contexts where competition exists between different land-uses, where urban sprawl is detrimental to undeveloped areas and where urban intensification is a policy objective. Show less
Current industrial production is driven by increasing globalization, which has led to a steady increase in production volumes and complexity of products aimed at the pursuit of meeting the needs of... Show moreCurrent industrial production is driven by increasing globalization, which has led to a steady increase in production volumes and complexity of products aimed at the pursuit of meeting the needs of customers. In this context, one of the main tools in the management of customer value is Lean Manufacturing or Production, though it is considered primarily as a set of tools to reduce the total cost of the resources needed to achieve such needs. This philosophy has recently been enriched in the literature with case studies that link Lean Management (LM) with the improvement of environmental sustainability. The consequence is an expansion of the Computer Integrated Manufacturing (CIM); indeed, CIM, currently, combining and integrating the key business functions (e.g., business, engineering, manufacturing, and information management) with a view of the life cycle, does not highlight the strategic role of the environmental aspects. In order to deal with the increasingly rapid environmental degradation that is reflected in society, in terms of both economy and quality of life, Industrial Ecology (IE) introduced a new paradigm of principles and instruments of analysis and decision support (e.g., Life Cycle AssessmentLCA, Social Life Cycle Assessment -SLCA, Material Flow AccountMFA, etc.) that can be considered as the main basis for integrating the environmental aspects in each strategy, design, production, final product, and end of life management, through the re-engineering of processes and activities towards the development of an eco-industrial system. This paper presents the preliminary observations based on a analysis of both theories (LM-IE) and provides a possible assessment of the key factors relevant to their integration in a lean environmental management, highlighting both positives (lights) and possible barriers (shadows). Show less