Two ships in the night or in the same boat together: how the ECJ squared the circle and foreshadowed Lisbon in its Kadi judgement

Larik, J.

Persistent URL of this record https://hdl.handle.net/1887/139136

View statistics

In Collections

This item can be found in the following collections:

Scholarly Publications

Larik, J. (2010)

Two ships in the night or in the same boat together: how the ECJ squared the circle and foreshadowed Lisbon in its Kadi judgement

Article / Letter to editor

This paper argues that the ECJ in its seminal Kadi judgment made the right decision and foreshadowed numerous reforms in the EU’s external action introduced by the Lisbon Treaty. It rightly rejected the approach presented by the Court of First Instance, which ultimately turned out to be a false friend of international law. By largely following the Advocate General’s Opinion, the Court maintained the superior human rights standard of the EU legal order. Without, however, jeopardizing the compliance of the Member States with their UN obligations right away, it sent a clear warning signal to the UN Security Council to exhaust the potential for reform of the targeted sanction regime. The Court showed that in the face of such global threats as terrorism as well as the undermining of basic human rights, we are all in the same boat together after all.

CJEU

European Court of Justice